| 2019-03-21 16:00:4003/21/2019 |   2019 Queensbury Warriors (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 9 - 10 | Scrimmage | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-03-29 16:30:3803/29/2019 |  2019 Guilderland Lady Dutchmen @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 7 - 15 | Suburban Council Varsity | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-04-02 16:15:5304/02/2019 |  2019 Colonie Garnet Raiders (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 0 - 19 | Suburban Council Varsity | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-04-04 16:15:0604/04/2019 |  2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Saratoga Blue Streaks (V) | 14 - 10 | Suburban Council Varsity | Saratoga Spings HS Stadium |
| 2019-04-06 11:00:4204/06/2019 |  2019 Averill Park Warriors (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 4 - 13 | Suburban Council Varsity | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-04-09 16:45:1504/09/2019 |  2019 BHBL Spartans (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 18 - 17 | Suburban Council Varsity | BH-BL High School Turf Field |
| 2019-04-11 17:30:4904/11/2019 |  2019 Niskayuna Silver Warriors (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 9 - 8 | Suburban Council Varsity | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-04-13 14:00:1204/13/2019 |  2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Westhill Warriors (V) | 1 - 17 | Non-League | Westhill High School |
| 2019-04-14 13:00:2604/14/2019 |  2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Marcellus Mustangs (V) | 9 - 8 | Non-League | Marcellus Stadium Field |
| 2019-04-16 18:30:3904/16/2019 |  2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Albany Falcons (V) | 21 - 1 | Suburban Council Varsity | Albany High School Turf |
| 2019-04-23 12:00:5004/23/2019 | 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Averill Park Warriors (V) | 18 - 7 | Suburban Council Varsity | Averill Park High School |
| 2019-04-25 12:00:0204/25/2019 |  2019 Ballston Spa Scotties (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 5 - 18 | Suburban Council Varsity | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-04-27 11:00:1004/27/2019 |  2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Columbia Blue Devils | 17 - 8 | Suburban Council Varsity | Columbia High School Turf |
| 2019-04-30 19:00:1404/30/2019 |  2019 Shaker Blue Bison (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) | 15 - 3 | Suburban Council Varsity | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-05-07 16:15:4605/07/2019 |  2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Bethlehem Eagles (V) | 7 - 8 | Suburban Council Varsity | Bethlehem High School Fields |
| 2019-05-09 19:30:4905/09/2019 | 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Niskayuna Silver Warriors (V) | 12 - 5 | Suburban Council Varsity | Niskayuna High School |
| 2019-05-14 16:15:4705/14/2019 | 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Guilderland Lady Dutchmen (V) | 15 - 10 | Suburban Council Varsity | Guilderland High School Lady Dutch Field |
| 2019-05-20 16:15:0805/20/2019 | 2019 Guilderland Lady Dutchmen (V) @ 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) Section 2 Semifinal | 9 - 10 | Suburban Council Varsity | Shenendehowa Turf Field |
| 2019-05-22 18:00:4005/22/2019 | 2019 Shenendehowa Plainsmen (V) @ 2019 Bethlehem Eagles (V) Section 2 Final | 12 - 15 | Suburban Council Varsity | |
